Past Sheriffs
| 1818 – 1820 | Joseph Westenhaver |
|---|---|
| 1821 – 1822 | Peter Haynes |
| 1823 – 1824 | Joseph Westenhaver |
| 1824 – 1826 | Daniel Harsh |
| 1827 – 1830 | Amos E. Bright |
| 1831 – 1834 | D.C. Myers |
| 1835 – 1838 | Eli Barker |
| 1839 – 1842 | Fred Mollenhower |
| 1834 – 1846 | William Nelson |
| 1847 – 1848 | Fred Mollenhower |
| 1849 – 1850 | Reuben Heston |
| 1851 – 1854 | M. Moore |
| 1855 – 1858 | Reuben Heston |
| 1859 – 1860 | J. M. Floyd |
| 1861 – 1864 | Henry Barker |
| 1864 – 1866 | W. M. Davey |
| 1867 – 1870 | W. T. Acker |
| 1871 – 1872 | W. M. Davey |
| 1873 – 1876 | Robert Corran |
| 1877 – 1878 | A. Steinman |
| 1878 – 1882 | James N. Acker |
| 1883 – 1886 | T. F. McCarthy |
| 1887 – 1890 | John Gallagher |
| 1891 – 1894 | Dan Wright |
| 1895 – 1898 | W. J. Ryan |
| 1899 – 1902 | Charles F. Brandt |
| 1903 – 1906 | James Thomas |
| 1907 – 1910 | George B. Williamson |
| 1911 – 1914 | Bundy Allen |
| 1915 – 1918 | Frank M. Stevens |
| 1919 – 1922 | Charles E. Larimer |
| 1923 – 1926 | William P. Shaw |
| 1927 – 1930 | William R. Lloyd |
| 1931 – 1934 | Sol Ellinger |
| 1935 – 1940 | Joe Farbean |
| 1941 – 1948 | Floyd Duffy |
| 1949 – 1960 | A. J. Waldron |
| 1961 – 1976 | Paul “Puffy” Hartman |
| 1977 – 1981 | Paul “Hap” Thrush |
| 1981 – 2000 | James P. Jones |
| 2001 – Present | Lanny E. North |